There’s a growing trend in the Netherlands at this moment in time; media personalities questioning Liverpool’s Virgil van Dijk.

The Liverpool captain has been in the firing line for a while with his nation, but particularly after the World Cup. He was seen as the cause of their problems in the summer and a big part of the reason it all went wrong.

That’s something he’s already bitten back at, going toe to toe with the journalist responsible for some of the harshest criticism in a press conference last week.

The question about his international future was raging long before that, though. Van Dijk didn’t particularly help that by leaving his future ambiguous after the summer before then deciding to continue under Xavi last month.

He will have, perhaps, been hoping to dispel some of the doubts with his performances during the international break. Instead, it seems he’s done the complete opposite.

Time for a successor

For instance, former internationals like Willy van de Kerkhof is now fully questioning whether it’s time to move on.

“Virgil van Dijk arguably ranks among the top five internationals we’ve ever had. He has meant a great deal to the Dutch national team,” he said.

“(But) I think it would be wise to look for a successor to Virgil in the national team.”

His brother René noted exactly the same thing on Omroep Brabant’s Willy en René Podcast.

“When he has to play against French attackers, they’re already gone before Van Dijk has even turned around. That’s really starting to become a problem. He gets outpaced regularly at Liverpool, too,” he added.

Sitting deeper

The solution, according to Willy, is the Liverpool defender sitting deeper. But that’s an issue under Xavi, who wants to play a high line.

“But that’s the issue with Xavi; he actually wants him to play further up the pitch. And you also have to look ahead to the European Championship in two years’ time. How good will he be then?” he added.

He wouldn’t be kicking the Liverpool defender out just yet, because there are positives, but he does think that Xavi needs to look at the alternatives in the squad.

“He’s a fantastic captain and can be very important in the dressing room,” he concluded.

“If he were to drop out now, you’d have to replace him anyway. You’ve got Van Hecke, Timber could step in, and there are other defenders playing in the English league.”

Virgil van Dijk – Club and Country Career and Achievements
Club / Country Period Appearances Goals Main honours and achievements
Groningen 2011–2013 66 7 Made his senior debut in 2011. No senior team trophies.
Celtic 2013–2015 115 15 Scottish Premiership: 2013/14, 2014/15.
Scottish League Cup: 2014/15.
Celtic Players’ Player of the Year: 2013/14.
Southampton 2015–2018 80 7 Southampton Player of the Season: 2015/16.
Appointed club captain in 2017. No senior team trophies.
Liverpool 2018–present 380 36 Premier League: 2019/20, 2024/25.
Champions League: 2018/19.
FA Cup: 2021/22.
League Cup: 2021/22, 2023/24.
UEFA Super Cup: 2019.
FIFA Club World Cup: 2019.
FA Community Shield: 2022.
Club captain since 2023.
Club career total 2011–present 641 65 12 senior club trophies, including the Community Shield.
Netherlands 2015–present 100 14 National-team captain since 2018.
UEFA Nations League runner-up: 2019.
World Cup quarter-finalist: 2022.
European Championship semi-finalist: 2024.
Reached 100 caps on 4 October 2026.
No senior international trophies.
Main Individual Achievements
PFA Players’ Player of the Year 2018/19
Premier League Player of the Season 2018/19
UEFA Men’s Player of the Year 2018/19
Ballon d’Or Runner-up in 2019
FIFPRO World 11 2019, 2020, 2022, 2024, 2025

Club figures cover senior first-team competitive matches across all
competitions. Netherlands figures cover senior internationals, including
friendlies. Youth and reserve appearances are excluded.
Sources: Liverpool FC, LFChistory, KNVB and published career records.
Figures checked on 7 October 2026.

Previous articleOliver Glasner aiming big for Nottingham Forest – Wants to copy Aston Villa
Sean Lunt
Experienced football journalist who has worked in the industry since 2015, specialising in transfer stories from across the world’s media. His career spans digital newsrooms, live match coverage, long‑form features and statistical analysis, with a particular focus on Premier League and European football. Sean has become an expert in how the football transfer business works and his reporting often brings clarity to fans. A long‑suffering Everton fan, he approaches every window with optimism and caution in equal measure.