Manchester United have reached that awkward point with Diogo Dalot where even taking him off gets a cheer.

During the 4-4 draw against Aston Villa, supporters applauded his substitution almost as enthusiastically as they would a goal.

You have probably heard Gary Neville has come to the Portuguese defender’s rescue. Now, a journalist back in Portugal has taken that argument a little further. And his conclusion might be uncomfortable for United.

Perhaps Dalot would be better off leaving. And as we covered earlier this month, looks like there will be no shortage of suitors.

From reliable defender to The Ugly Duckling

Writing in his weekly column for A Bola, editor Hugo Vasconcelos has given Dalot a rather unfortunate nickname: “The ugly duckling of Old Trafford.”

It’s a reference to the famous fairy tale, although Vasconcelos doesn’t appear convinced this particular ugly duckling will ever get his happy ending in Manchester.

His argument starts with Neville’s recent defence of the 27-year-old.

“Dalot is an easy target. Of course he could be better at everything he does, but if he played in a decent back four, he’d do alright,” the former United right-back said.

Vasconcelos doesn’t disagree. In fact, he makes a decent case for Neville’s point by looking at what happened with Portugal this week.

Against Wales in Cardiff, Sorba Thomas was causing all sorts of problems down Portugal’s right. He’d already scored and showed little intention of slowing down.

So Jorge Jesus made a change. He switched Dalot to right-back and moved the more celebrated João Cancelo across to the left. And it worked.

As Vasconcelos puts it, when Portugal needed someone to stop the Welsh sprinter, “it was Dalot Jorge Jesus turned to. Successfully.”

The journalist acknowledges the obvious shortcomings. Dalot’s crossing could be better, and his defensive positioning sometimes lets him down.

But he makes another observation: “When someone tries to beat him for pace, or in a one-on-one, he’s among the most reliable.”

When the fans have had enough

Diogo Dalot
Diogo Dalot of Manchester United during the UEFA Champions League League Phase MD2 match between Atletico de Madrid and Manchester United at Riyadh Air Metropolitano on October 13, 2026 in Madrid, Spain

Vasconcelos isn’t suggesting Manchester United have a world-class defender on their hands. He even writes that Dalot is far from suddenly turning into one of the world’s best full-backs at 27.

What bothers him is the scale of the criticism. He points out that the Portuguese international was playing at left-back against Aston Villa. Plenty of his teammates were making mistakes too, yet his substitution received that extraordinary reaction.

“There are players like this, competent without being brilliant, who supporters eventually grow tired of,” Vasconcelos writes. And that’s really the heart of his argument.

Dalot might never produce the sort of performances that make people forget his weaknesses. But that doesn’t automatically make him the problem United supporters seem to believe he is.

In the end, Vasconcelos seems to think the relationship with the crowd might already be too damaged for that to matter.

“Once that happens, it’s very difficult to turn things around. The best thing is to move on.”

Sport Witness Library: Dalot career to date

DIOGO DALOT
Career record · Club appearances, goals & honours
Sport Witness
301 first-team club appearances  |
12 goals  |
42 Portugal caps  |
3 international goals
Club Period League apps Total apps Total goals
FC Porto 2017–2018 6 8 0
Manchester United 2018–present 183 260 10
AC Milan — loan 2020–2021 21 33 2
FIRST-TEAM TOTAL All competitions 210 301 12
Porto B: An additional 23 appearances and two goals in Portugal’s second division during 2016/17 and 2017/18. Including these gives 324 senior club appearances and 14 goals.
MANCHESTER UNITED: SEASON BY SEASON
Season Apps Goals
2018/19 23 0
2019/20 11 1
2020/21* 1 0
2021/22 30 0
2022/23 42 2
2023/24 50 3
2024/25 53 3
2025/26 36 1
2026/27 so far 14 0
UNITED TOTAL 260 10
HONOURS & RECOGNITION
Primeira Liga FC Porto · 2017/18
League Cup Manchester United · 2022/23
FA Cup Manchester United · 2023/24
UEFA Nations League Portugal · 2024/25
European Under-17 Championship Portugal · 2016
Players’ Player of the Year Manchester United · 2023/24
Position: Full-back, capable of playing on either side.
United arrival: Signed from Porto in June 2018; made his debut against Young Boys on 19 September 2018.
Portugal: 42 senior appearances and three goals since his debut in June 2021.
*2020/21: Made one United appearance before joining AC Milan on loan.
Scope: Competitive first-team club matches across all competitions, including the Community Shield. Porto B appearances are shown separately and excluded from the first-team total. International figures cover senior Portugal matches, including friendlies. Youth club matches excluded.
Updated: 19 November 2026. Club figures through 8 November; Portugal figures through 17 November 2026.
SPORT WITNESS