Stephen Warnock has explained why he thinks Liverpool were right to avoid appointing Xabi Alonso as their new manager this summer.

The Reds found themselves hunting for a new manager earlier this year after electing to part ways with Arne Slot at the end of last season.

The Dutch manager led them to the Premier League title in his first season in charge after replacing Jurgen Klopp in 2024. But his second season proved to be a disastrous one.

The Reds eventually finished the campaign trophyless and 25 points behind champions Arsenal.

Liverpool elected to head in a different direction, eventually settling on the appointment of Andoni Iraola. But that was not before Alonso had been heavily linked with the position.

Alonso links

The former midfielder remains a firm favourite at Anfield. He spent five seasons as a Red, making 210 appearances and winning the Champions League, Super Cup, FA Cup and Community Shield.

He’s been seriously linked with the Liverpool job on two separate occasions as a result. The first time came in 2024 when Klopp departed.

The Spaniard was the immediate overwhelming favourite at that point after leading Bayer Leverkusen to an unbeaten Bundesliga and DFB-Pokal double that season. He eventually publicly ruled himself out in March 2024, staying at Leverkusen for another year. Liverpool then pivoted and appointed Slot.

Alonso was then in the mix again after leaving Real Madrid in January this year. Spanish, German and English reports all insisted he was high on Liverpool’s list as things unravelled under Slot.

Again, though, when the time come to making an appointment, Liverpool went in another direction. Alonso, meanwhile, ended up joining Chelsea.

Watching Chelsea closely

Stephen Warnock was one of those who never saw the Spaniard being the right fit. He felt that any appointment would be built on nostalgia. That’s an opinion he stands by as he watches Alonso at Chelsea.

“Yes, I still think it would have been a nostalgic appointment,” he told Sport Witness.

“He is a young manager learning at a huge club.

“He did an amazing job at Leverkusen, and turning down Real Madrid would have been incredibly difficult. But there is something to be said for spending time at a level where you can make mistakes and learn from them.

“At Real Madrid or Chelsea, you can lose your job before you get that opportunity.

“Iraola made mistakes at Bournemouth and can now draw on those experiences.

“The wider problem is that a manager goes a couple of games without winning and people immediately say he is not good enough.

“Players lose confidence, managers lose confidence, and sometimes you need time to rebuild.

“I still think Alonso will do well at Chelsea, but there could be difficult periods before everything comes together.”

Warnock was speaking to Sport Witness on behalf of betTOM. 

Sport Witness Library: Alonso at Liverpool

XABI ALONSO
Liverpool career · 2004–2009
Sport Witness
210 appearances  |
19 goals  |
Five seasons  |
Champions League winner
Season Premier League apps Other apps Total apps Total goals
2004/05 24 8 32 3
2005/06 35 18 53 5
2006/07 32 19 51 4
2007/08 19 8 27 2
2008/09 33 14 47 5
LIVERPOOL TOTAL 143 67 210 19
HONOURS AT LIVERPOOL
UEFA Champions League 2004/05 · Scored Liverpool’s equaliser in the Istanbul final against AC Milan.
UEFA Super Cup 2005 · Liverpool beat CSKA Moscow 3–1 after extra time.
FA Cup 2005/06 · Started the final against West Ham, won by Liverpool on penalties.
FA Community Shield 2006 · Appeared as a substitute in the 2–1 victory over Chelsea.
CAREER HIGHLIGHTS
Arrival Joined from Real Sociedad in August 2004, becoming a central figure in Rafael Benítez’s midfield.
Istanbul, 2005 Converted the rebound from his saved penalty to complete Liverpool’s comeback from 3–0 down to 3–3.
Long-range goals Scored from inside his own half against Luton Town and Newcastle United in 2006.
Further title challenges Champions League runner-up in 2006/07 and Premier League runner-up in 2008/09.
Departure Left for Real Madrid in August 2009 after five seasons at Anfield.
Scope: Liverpool senior competitive appearances only. Other appearances include domestic cups, European competitions and qualifiers, the FIFA Club World Championship and Community Shield. Goals cover all competitions. Youth matches, friendlies and legends fixtures excluded.
Updated: 19 November 2026.
SPORT WITNESS

 

Previous articleBournemouth highly likely to discuss January deal – Transfer makes sense for everyone
Sean Lunt
Experienced football journalist who has worked in the industry since 2015, specialising in transfer stories from across the world’s media. His career spans digital newsrooms, live match coverage, long‑form features and statistical analysis, with a particular focus on Premier League and European football. Sean has become an expert in how the football transfer business works and his reporting often brings clarity to fans. A long‑suffering Everton fan, he approaches every window with optimism and caution in equal measure.