Crystal Palace midfielder Quinten Timber isn’t good enough for the Netherlands and his international career should be at an end.

That appears to be the growing consensus in the Netherlands following their shocking 5-0 defeat to Germany on Monday.

Xavi’s side were roundly dismantled by the Germans on Monday evening, suffering their worst defeat since 1959. The response has been typically dramatic since.

While some were insisting that nobody came out looking well – with Tottenham’s Jan Paul van Hecke getting the best score with a six – others have been much harsher. And much of that harsh criticism has been aimed at Crystal Palace’s Timber.

He started the game in central midfield alongside Joey Veerman and Tijjani Reijnders. But it proved to be a chastening evening, to say the least. And for some, it should be the end.

What the pundits are saying

On Rondo, Wim Kieft stated that, as far as he is concerned, Quinten Timber’s time with the national team should be over.

“We’ve seen enough of Timber now. His play is too erratic, he lacks dominance, and there’s no consistency. He’s simply not good enough,” he said.

Fellow panellist Theo Janssen was in complete agreement on that point.

“He’s often not really involved. He just drifts around, jogs through the middle. He isn’t dominant, he doesn’t add any pace… You could say: I’ll opt for Gjivai Zechiel or Sean Steur – a different type of player. What Timber offers just isn’t good enough.”

Tactical mistake

Crystal Palace

Journalist Valentijn Driessen went one step further in his analysis in De Telegraaf. He labelled the decision to use the Crystal Palace midfielder as a “tactical blunder”.

“Initially, he offered the wrong solution to cover for the absence of Frenkie de Jong by bringing in Quinten Timber.

“In adjusting his side, the Spaniard didn’t prioritize ball possession; instead, he opted for the physically imposing Quinten Timber to engage in a physical battle with the German midfield.

“With the pairing of De Jong and Joey Veerman, the build-up play against Greece was handled well, but with Timber, it was completely ineffective.”

Sport Witness Analysis: Timber stats

QUINTEN TIMBER
Club career & 2026/27 Crystal Palace statistics
Sport Witness
25 years old  |
Netherlands midfielder  |
Crystal Palace
FIRST-TEAM CLUB CAREER
Club Period Appearances Goals
FC Utrecht 2021–2022 33 2
Feyenoord 2022–2026 125 21
Marseille 2026 17 0
Crystal Palace 2026–present 10 0
FIRST-TEAM TOTAL All competitions 185 23
Jong Ajax: An additional 40 appearances and three goals in the Dutch second division between 2018 and 2021.

Including Jong Ajax: 225 appearances and 26 goals in senior club competitions. He made no competitive appearances for Ajax’s first team.

THIS SEASON · CRYSTAL PALACE 2026/27
Competition Apps Starts Minutes Goals Assists
Premier League 6 6 450 0 1
Europa League 3 3 203 0 0
League Cup 1 1 59 0 0
PALACE TOTAL 10 10 712 0 1
Full 2026/27 season: Also played once for Marseille before joining Palace on 1 September. His combined season record is 11 appearances, 758 minutes, no goals and one assist.

Feyenoord record: The Dutch club confirmed 125 appearances, 21 goals and 17 assists when he left in January 2026.

Senior club honours: Eredivisie winner, 2022/23; KNVB Cup winner, 2023/24; Johan Cruyff Shield winner, 2024 — all with Feyenoord.

Scope: Competitive club matches only. First-team totals exclude Jong Ajax, which is listed separately. Figures include domestic cups, European competition, qualifying rounds and Utrecht’s European qualification play-offs. Youth matches, friendlies and internationals are excluded.

Minutes: Follow Opta’s records; providers can differ slightly in their treatment of substitution times.

Updated: 17 November 2026.

SPORT WITNESS