Taty Castellanos wants to leave West Ham United. 

It’s not the first time we’ve heard this to be fair. But this time while his future in London is being questioned, the Argentine striker already seems to know where he doesn’t want to go: back to South America, for starters.

The 28-year-old has apparently rejected a lucrative offer from Flamengo, while River Plate’s hopes of finally signing him are fading. Castellanos, it seems, still has unfinished business in European football.

“He wants to leave West Ham”

Argentine journalist Renzo Pantich has been discussing Castellanos’ future, with his comments now picked up by El Intransigente.

The conversation initially centred on River Plate, who have been linked with the striker again ahead of the January transfer window. But Pantich dropped a rather more interesting detail along the way.

“He wants to leave West Ham. Many people had already started presenting him as a possibility, or saying River had set their sights on him.”

Pantich didn’t explain why the striker wants to leave, or whether he’s already communicated that desire to West Ham. There’s also no suggestion of formal negotiations with another European club.

What the journalist did explain, however, is that leaving England wouldn’t necessarily mean returning home.

“Well, the footballer isn’t planning to return to South America. In fact, he rejected an offer from Flamengo and also intends to stay in Europe for a while longer.”

And apparently, money wasn’t enough to change his mind.

“It’s two plus two. He doesn’t want to, even if River come in, and even though he’s mentioned several times that he has a soft spot for River and likes the club.”

“He rejected Flamengo despite a huge amount of money being offered because he wants to continue in Europe. It seems his thinking is still very much about staying in Europe.”

So, according to Pantich, Castellanos wants out of West Ham but isn’t ready to leave European football. That potentially makes his situation rather more complicated for the London club.

River Plate have heard this story before

Taty Castellanos
Taty Castellanos

River’s interest in Castellanos goes back several years, and they’ve already missed out on him twice.

The first occasion came when he was a youngster trying to break into professional football. As we covered earlier this year, Castellanos revealed that River rejected him during a trial because he was considered too skinny.

Then, in 2022, Marcelo Gallardo wanted him as a replacement for Julián Álvarez, who was heading to Manchester City.

By that point, Castellanos was starring for New York City FC. The American club wanted €15m, which River couldn’t afford, and the striker eventually joined Girona.

Now River are looking for attacking reinforcements again, with Castellanos back on their list of possible targets.

Pantich, however, believes the prospect is already losing momentum. There’s been no official offer from River, and the player’s apparent determination to remain in Europe makes another attempt look difficult.

So West Ham could be left with an awkward question to answer in January: what happens if their striker really does want out, but only on his own terms?

Sport Witness Analysis: Taty stats

TATY CASTELLANOS
Senior club career & 2026/27 season statistics
Sport Witness
339 career appearances  |
111 goals  |
Current club: West Ham United
SENIOR CLUB CAREER
Club Period Appearances Goals
Universidad de Chile 2017 1 0
Torque 2017–2018 30 5
New York City FC 2018–2022 134 59
Girona · loan 2022–2023 37 14
Lazio 2023–2026 98 22
West Ham United 2026–present 39 11
CAREER TOTAL All competitions 339 111
WEST HAM UNITED · 2026/27
Competition Apps Starts Minutes Goals Assists
Championship 14 9 879 1 4
League Cup 3 1 146 3 0
SEASON TOTAL 17 10 1,025 4 4
Career highlights: MLS Cup winner and MLS Golden Boot winner with New York City FC in 2021. Scored all four Girona goals in a 4–2 victory over Real Madrid in April 2023.

West Ham record: Seven goals in 22 appearances during 2025/26, followed by four goals in 17 appearances this season.

Scope: Senior first-team competitive club matches. Career figures include domestic cups, continental competitions and MLS play-offs. Youth matches, friendlies and internationals are excluded. Torque is now known as Montevideo City Torque. Season minutes and assists follow Opta.

Updated: 17 November 2026.

SPORT WITNESS