Bruno Spindel, once a director at Flamengo, has shed light on one of the club’s most debated signings in recent years. Everton’s Carlos Alcaraz.
Speaking to Brazilian outlet Globo Esporte, the longtime executive addressed the process that led to the arrival and quick departure of the Argentine midfielder. Alcaraz then joined Everton on loan before the move was made permanent.
Spindel spent nearly 13 years at Flamengo and was considered one of the key figures behind the club’s modern era. He explained that the deal for Alcaraz was part of a long-term scouting plan. “The decisions were made in well-structured meetings between the scouting department and the coaching staff,” he said.
“Alcaraz, for example, was monitored by different heads of scouting over time, showing continuity in the process. He was a young player who was part of the squad’s renewal strategy.
Asked whether the price paid for the midfielder had been excessive given his short stay, Spindel defended the club’s transfer strategy. “The value was right. If you check, he moved from Argentina to Europe for almost the same fee,” he stated.
“‘Charly had a good season at Southampton in the Premier League, which is the most competitive league in the world. We had tried to sign him before, and I think he left too soon, after only three months. He didn’t have time to develop or create market value. But the price was fair.”
Transfer to Everton seen as vindication
Spindel also emphasised that Alcaraz’s ability to adapt to English football, as shown at Everton, validated Flamengo’s original assessment. “He was approved by the scouts and could play in several positions. That’s why he’s now playing in the Premier League. He just needed more time to perform here,” the director added.
“I respect the decision to let him go, but I don’t believe signing him was a mistake”, he concluded.
Having joined Flamengo in 2012 and served under multiple presidents, Spindel played a central role in the club’s most successful period, overseeing 13 major trophies and several record transfers.
His comments now offer a rare inside look at how a Premier League regular briefly passed through Rio de Janeiro on his way back to England, and Everton.
